possible additions thread

[akar]

My CD Winner card is also an error.
You should consider the possibility that both the C Winner and the CD Winner were both uncorrected errors.

There are no pictures of the corrected versions on here.
They may not exist.
And people that think they have them may not have examined them closely.
I never bothered to look closely at the CD Winner until now.

So maybe you can convince someone to post some scans of both the C Winner and the CD Winner.
And if no one out of all these major Juan collectors has one, then we could probably assume there was never a correction issued.

[freddie]

Originally Posted by akar

My CD Winner card is also an error.
You should consider the possibility that both the C Winner and the CD Winner were both uncorrected errors.

There are no pictures of the corrected versions on here.
They may not exist.
And people that think they have them may not have examined them closely.
I never bothered to look closely at the CD Winner until now.

So maybe you can convince someone to post some scans of both the C Winner and the CD Winner.
And if no one out of all these major Juan collectors has one, then we could probably assume there was never a correction issued.

Yes, that has occurred to me. If Rob has the same error then we'll just remove the error cards and mark the normal card as UER.

[nosterbor]

Originally Posted by freddie

Yes, that has occurred to me. If Rob has the same error then we'll just remove the error cards and mark the normal card as UER.

i only have the error.

[freddie]

I've removed the error cards and updated the normal cards to have an UER designation.

[freddie]

2725 sent me his list, where he has both the normal and error versions of the C and C/D cards. He also correctly notes that error cards are picturing the National League players.

[akar]

I also used to have a C Winner and C Winner Error on my list.
But I have never actually seen the C Winner with the correct players.
Maybe Dan can scan it for you.

Thinking about it, it doesn't seem likely for a company to issue a correction for a redemption card error. They aren't expecting people to keep or collect them. They only expect you to have them a short time until you mail it in.

[freddie]

Originally Posted by akar

I also used to have a C Winner and C Winner Error on my list.
But I have never actually seen the C Winner with the correct players.
Maybe Dan can scan it for you.

Thinking about it, it doesn't seem likely for a company to issue a correction for a redemption card error. They aren't expecting people to keep or collect them. They only expect you to have them a short time until you mail it in.

He has them on his list as having them, I'll ask him about them when I am done going through his list and entering it for him.